Vibration, heat and power plays: Lab design determines scientific success

The very best equipment can be compromised from the outset if you fail to take proper care when fitting out your laboratory, cautions Brian J Ford.

Conference chatter is always the same: we are guarded about progress (nobody wants to give away secrets before they’re officially announced), cautious about personnel (people persistently poach), guarded about money (too little sounds like you missed out on the last round, too much amounts to bragging) – but instrumentation? When it comes to celebrating the latest acquisition, and your state-of-the-art equipment, delegates are as open as a suitcase at security.

In today’s environment of high-precision science, instrumentation is only part of the equation. It is the laboratory environment that matters as much. Your benches, services, structure and systems can either safeguard data acquisition or silently undermine everything you hope to achieve.

Poor decisions at fit-out can introduce vibration, thermal drift, electrical interference or airflow turbulence that can render even the most expensive equipment unreliable. This is especially critical when you compare retrofit projects with a new-build laboratory.

The laboratory environment was traditionally relegated way down the list. I knew Professor CR Burch at the University of Bristol, who would ruefully recount the difficulties he encountered when polishing concave mirrors with an unprecedented degree of accuracy. Burch created magnificent microscopes weighing the best part of 100 kilogrammes and designed to work with ultraviolet, since this offered unprecedented resolution. UV is not transmissible by glass lenses, so Burch had to polish concave mirrors to generate his images. “The equipment was well matched to the task,” he told me, “but it was the situation of the laboratory that presented me with problems.”

Burch recounted how he would come into the university and work between two and five in the morning, because at all other times distant traffic would create sufficient vibrations to interfere with the accuracy of his mirrors. “The equipment was superb,” he said. “It was secured on mounts of vulcanised rubber. But traffic put paid to all that effort.”

Working at night was the only way his research could proceed.

Compare that with the specialist fit-out at the new Cavendish Laboratory at Cambridge University, where I conduct much of my electron microscopy. This world famous laboratory has now been subsumed into the Ray Dolby Centre, conceived as a holistic engineering achievement where every aspect of the building is meticulously crafted to facilitate the most sensitive scientific investigations. This new facility was designed to meet rigorous vibration criterion (VC) standards, ranging from VC-A (50 µm/s) for standard laboratories to the exceptionally stringent VC-H (0.39 µm/s) for the most sensitive installations.

Poor decisions at fit-out can introduce vibration, thermal drift, electrical interference or airflow turbulence that can render even the most expensive equipment unreliable. This is especially critical when you compare retrofit projects with a new-build laboratory

The equipment is now housed in an eight metre deep basement, which sits on a colossal concrete raft up to three metres thick. A key innovation has been the use of separate Central Utility Buildings (CUBs) that are structurally isolated from the main research wings. The building’s plant, like air conditioning, are situated in these CUBs to minimise the chance of vibration reaching the laboratories. The design was supported by vibration consultants ISVR Consulting who carried out extensive testing and monitoring throughout both design and construction. Precast concrete units with joints were replaced by a reinforced concrete frame cast in situ and 350 millimetres thick, providing a monolithic structure that further restricted vibration.

Face it: vibration is the silent killer of precision. So many instruments – not only electron microscopes, but atomic force microscopes, delicate digital balances, NMR spectrometers, and the rest – are extraordinarily sensitive to external vibration. Foot traffic, nearby plant rooms, lifts and HVAC fans can transmit low-frequency energy throughout a building. Structural engineers frequently rely on add-on solutions such as pneumatic insulators, physical isolators, active vibration cancellation tables, or optical breadboards equipped with tuned dampers. All can be effective, but it makes far more sense to create a well-designed low-vibration laboratory from the start.

Mass and rigidity dampen high frequency response. Granite worktops or those made from heavy epoxy resin will perform far better than lightweight laminate or wooden benches. Anti-vibration mounts or decoupled tops are essential for microbalances and high magnification imaging. Many laboratories are fitted with existing benches that are lightweight or poorly anchored, and replacing these can be disruptive and costly, leading laboratories to compromise with partial upgrades. Far better to design from the start.

Fluctuations in temperature as small as 0.1°C can shift baselines in chromatography, spectroscopy or metrology. Air currents and poorly placed diffusers or fume hoods create eddies that can affect balances and unprotected sample material.

A professional fit-out today recognises the importance of electrical power quality and electronic infrastructure, for modern instrumentation demands clean, stable power. Voltage spikes are a recognised hazard, but harmonics created by large motors and poor earthing can introduce noise into detectors and analysers.

Analytical instruments require dedicated radial circuits, and uninterruptible power supplies with isolation transformers. Surge protection goes without saying.

Modern fume hoods are a component of general ventilation and are essential for safety – but can be enemies of precision. Traditional high-velocity exhaust systems create vibration and fluctuations in pressure, while turbulent airflow can compromise your specimens. Modern high-efficiency fans are designed to be low vibration, and should be located remotely. Supply diffusers can minimise direct impingement on instrumentation, and balanced air systems can avoid strong pressure gradients.

It makes far more sense to create a well-designed low-vibration laboratory from the start

New labs are going up everywhere. They offer the luxury of designing performance in from day one. Structural, mechanical and electrical systems can be holistically optimised and although the capital cost is higher the long-term instrumentation uptime, data quality and energy efficiency will prove superior in the long term.

The best performing laboratories treat fit-out as an extension of instrumentation, and early engagement between architects, engineers, facility managers and scientific users – particularly the instrument specialists – is essential. Extra expenditure during the fit-out phase can save hundreds of thousands in lost productivity, recalibration, or premature instrumentation replacement over the lifetime of your laboratory. In an era of tightening research budgets and increasingly sensitive analytical techniques, the quality of the laboratory environment is no longer a background consideration, for it is a determinant of scientific success.

When you look at a modern laboratory, like the Ray Dolby Centre in Cambridge, you can only sympathise with CR Burch, obliged to get up in the middle of the night to conduct his experiments in the only vibration-free environment he knew. Today, the university could have designed a functional laboratory from the start, and Professor Burch would have had a decent night’s sleep.

  • Professor Brian J Ford is a biologist, author, lecturer and broadcaster. He is also an Honorary Fellow of the Linnean Society and of the Royal Microscopical Society

Related Content

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This