The design challenge of instrument reliability in automated labs

As laboratories become more connected, data reliability is becoming a systems issue. Where once instrument performance was shaped by the wider lab environment, now the interaction between instruments within integrated systems is itself a key influence upon planning, explain Eric Heidt, Regal Leftwich and Sarah Corbitt.
Scientific laboratories are rapidly evolving from collections of independent instruments into interconnected ecosystems of automation, data systems and hybrid scientific workflows. As research organisations adopt artificial intelligence/machine learning (AI/ ML) assisted experimentation, robotic sample handling, remote monitoring and shared instrumentation strategies, the increasing need for operational integration and digital connectivity is challenging traditional approaches to laboratory planning. Instrument reliability is no longer defined solely by environmental stability and utility coordination, but also by how instruments interact, exchange data and function within highly automated workflows.
Designing these next-generation labs requires new approaches to infrastructure planning, equipment clustering, network capacity, environmental zoning and longterm flexibility. By treating instruments as components of an integrated scientific operating system rather than isolated devices, organisations can improve operational resilience, increase utilisation and create laboratory environments that adapt to rapidly evolving research technologies.
Environmental sensitivity amplified by next-gen instruments
In an automated, networked lab, environmental sensitivity is no longer a single-instrument problem, but a systemwide risk. With instruments feeding data directly into the next step of an automated workflow, the impact of bad data becomes exponential, leaving fewer opportunities for human review to identify questionable data. More advanced instruments measure with greater precision, which means greater sensitivity to their environment.
The impact of a small environmental disturbance on one instrument’s data now cascades throughout the workflow, generating a stream of unreliable results.
Consequently, the combination of more sensitive instruments with automated workflows requires greater care in determining where and how instruments are placed in the lab to limit the risk of an instrument’s bad output destroying a complete data set. An instrument’s proximity to windows, mechanical rooms or high-traffic corridors carries more weight now, with less human oversight to compensate for a lessthan-ideal location. Vibration is a clear example. Electron microscopes and precision metrology equipment can lose accuracy from vibration generated by nearby mechanical systems As instrumentation controls have become smaller and more sensitive, building vibration has a significant impact on longterm research performance.

Projects with tight vibration criteria often call for special floor treatments, such as topping slabs and placement near structural columns, to mitigate disruptive movement.
Greater sensitivity has made other instruments more at risk from poor temperature control. A mass spectrometer or chromatograph can drift when room temperature exceeds its operating tolerance. On a recent project involving highresolution imaging and testing equipment for the quality control lab in a sterile injectable drug manufacturing plant, glass was fitted with ultraviolet (UV) protective film specifically to limit UV exposure and heat gain that could otherwise introduce micron-scale measurement errors. These examples confirm a new reality in lab planning: the design of facility layouts and systems is a prerequisite for instrument reliability.
Where reliability breaks down
In automated sequences, subtle instrument drift poses a bigger risk than outright failure. A dead instrument stops a workflow and gets noticed immediately; a drifting one continues producing data that looks plausible, and nothing in the automated sequence is designed to flag it as wrong. For instance, a new highresolution imaging system may necessitate tighter environmental and operational tolerances than the unit being replaced. A common and costly assumption about maintenance then compounds the problem.
Automation and AI change the approach to scheduling maintenance and calibration by shifting the cadence model from fixed schedules to condition-based needs. Many new-generation tools include builtin monitoring and predictive maintenance capabilities, just as building automation systems (BAS) monitor the environment. Increasingly, these tools report to a laboratory management system (LMS) or a digitalenhanced asset management platform, which is the networked AI ‘brain’ that pulls sensor data on operations and utility use, to drive lifecycle and maintenance scheduling.

This collection of monitoring systems, however, only works with planned integration and programming around real instrument diagnostics and performance data from the start, rather than layered on after the fact. Without that foundation, predictive maintenance systems are only as reliable as the assumptions built into them.
The same gap shows up in standard operating procedures (SOPs). Many labs still rely on traditional, static SOPs, missing the opportunity to build dynamic, digital SOPs into automated workflows. Operating on realtime instrument performance, dynamic SOPs can run through checklists and confirm digital approval or trigger an interlock, reducing the risk of human error. Left unaddressed, these gaps mean the tools meant to increase reliability can end up masking the very problems they were designed to catch.
Designing preventive measures
Reliability and quality management need to be addressed at the facility level, not the instrument level, to manage the performance of the entire research ecosystem. Frameworks such as ASTM E2500 (Standard Guide for Specification, Design and Verification of Pharmaceutical and Biopharmaceutical Manufacturing Systems and Equipment) [1] reinforce this shift, calling for systems and equipment to be verified as fit for their intended use within the full manufacturing environment rather than validated instrument by instrument.
A systems view reveals harder trade-offs than labs have faced before. Balancing human amenities such as daylighting and views against equipment sensitivity to UV exposure and heat gain, for example, now carries real consequences for data quality. Some practical design approaches used in recent projects illustrate the opportunities:
- Placement and zoning: Zoning by environmental requirements [2] rather thandepartment, and grouping instrumentation, hazardous materials and support functions accordingly improves equipment performance and safety [3].
- Maintainability [4]: By considering maintenance workflows when planning equipment access, utility distribution and service clearances within a pharmaceutical manufacturing support facility, teams can calibrate, service and replace equipment with minimal disruption to adjacent operations.
- Resiliency over redundancy: Rather than rely solely on redundant systems, a bioprocess innovation centre was designed around reliable utility infrastructure and environmental monitoring, building confidence in experimental consistency and reducing operational risk.
- Flexible infrastructure [5]: The same bioprocess innovation centre was planned with modular lab layouts and adaptable utility infrastructure, enabling teams to support new equipment and workflows without major renovations as research programmes mature. No single approach works in isolation. A matrix of smart design decisions works together to support a research environment that holds up as instruments, workflows and priorities evolve.
Old instruments, new systems
Most labs are layers of instruments from different eras, resulting in AI-driven instruments operating alongside instruments that were never designed to be networked. Shifting to AI-enabled research requires integrating these multiple generations of technology into a single connected ecosystem. Yet legacy instruments, built for standalone operation, manual input and local software, become a blind spot once the rest of the lab is running on system- and AI-monitored testing infrastructure.
The challenge is as much about facility planning as it is about integration. Bridging old and new requires infrastructure most legacy labs weren’t built for: different utility connections, network capacity, cybersecurity and power quality. Facilities need someone with an end-to-end view of the full ecosystem, capable of judging where a legacy instrument still fits and where it’s a weak link. It’s crucial to carefully plan new and upgraded laboratories so legacy and next-generation technologies can operate together while consistently delivering reliable data.
Evolving tech is changing humans’ role
The growth of automation and AI in laboratories is recasting the human role from hands-on execution toward oversight, validation and process-level decision-making. Regulatory frameworks reflect this shift. Guidance such as the EMA’s Annex 22 (Artificial Intelligence) [6] requires a human to remain in the loop for critical process decisions, reinforcing that automation augments judgment rather than replaces it. Human oversight and validation are critical safeguards that identify and address technology failures before they propagate downstream.
People need space to collaborate, communicate about validation, troubleshoot performance and verify that automated processes are working as intended. Because fewer instruments operate independently, their reliability can’t be isolated from their environments or the operators managing them. All three spheres demand careful design as an integrated, dynamic ecosystem to achieve consistent scientific outcomes.

- Regal Leftwich is principal and laboratory planning director at Hanbury

- Eric Heidt is associate principal and senior architect at Hanbury

- Sarah Corbitt is associate principal and laboratory planner at Hanbury
Captions:
1 Flexible laboratory infrastructure with modular utility distribution and adaptable workstations supports evolving research programmes, enabling new equipment and workflows to be integrated with minimal disruption.
2 Modern laboratories often combine legacy and next-generation instrumentation within a shared environment. Careful planning helps integrate older and newer technologies to support reliable workflows and data quality.
3 Designing for maintainability, including equipment access, utility distribution and service clearances, allows routine maintenance and equipment replacement to occur with minimal disruption to adjacent operations. Source: All images – Hanbury
References:
1 ASTM 2500-20 (Standard Guide for Specification, Design, and Verification of Pharmaceutical and Biopharmaceutical Manufacturing Systems and Equipment) https://store.astm.org/e2500-20.html
2 UNC Lineberger Comprehensive Cancer Center - Advanced Cellular Therapeutics Facility, https://unclineberger.org/act-facility/
3 Syngenta North American Crop Protection HQ, https://www.hanbury.design/projects/t2_syngenta_north_american_crop_protection_headquarters
4 Research Triangle Park – Manufacturing Support Laboratory, https://www.hanbury.design/projects/vgxi-headquarters-andbiomanufacturing-facility
5 VGXI HQ + Biomanufacturing Facility https://www.hanbury.design/projects/ vgxi-headquarters-andbiomanufacturing-facility
6 EMA Annex 22 (Artificial Intelligence), https://health.ec.europa.eu/document/download/5f38a92d-bb8e4264-8898-ea076e926db6_en?filename=mp_vol4_chap4_annex22_consultation_guideline_en.pdf

